Memo, Notes -- Baka News(gengo言語) 言葉使い(ことば遣い)表記、誤用、誤記、文法間違い…について語ろう (Language) #71

71ID非表示:2016/09/30(金) 13:22:45.47 ID:???


2 This is obviously wrong. "This is the cat that killed the rat that ate the malt that lay in the house that Jack built." – TKR yesterday


That seems wrong. Could you give an example? – lemontree yesterday


1 Yes he's either wrong, or using the terms "relative clause/relativized" in an unusual way. Can you post a larger excerpt of the passage where he claims this, as well as his Japanese examples of "further relativization"? – leoboiko yesterday


1 @TKR - your sample is not nested. This is: "The rat that the cat that Jack has was eaten." – amI 6 hours ago


1 @aml The question as stated seems to be whether NPs in a relative clause can themselves be relativized (i.e. be the antecedent of a relative clause), which they are in the example I gave. But this may be a bad formulation (see Greg Lee's answer). – TKR 4 hours ago


スパムを通報

このレスがスパム・荒らしである場合は以下のボタンをクリックして通報してください。
(同意できない意見などに反対票を投じる機能ではありません)
通報

このスレッドを全て表示


レスを書き込む

このスレッドはID非表示です。